Elementary School Scoring Rubric

Click here to download the full detailed rubric

Download the Rubric
Component #1 - Class Project / Total Possible - 45 points

Guiding Questions

  • Why did the class choose to do this project? What is the need for this project?
  • Why would this project be important to the community/school?
  • How did outside resources add to the project goals?
  • In what ways did the project help students master critical-thinking skills that will prepare them to evaluate issues and make informed decisions regarding stewardship of the planet?
  • How was the project integral to students learning standards based content?
  • How did this project improve upon or enhance student learning beyond the regular classroom curriculum?
  • In what ways did the project help students master critical thinking skills that will prepare them to evaluate issues and make informed decisions regarding stewardship of the planet?
  • In what ways were students actively involved in the selection, research, investigation and evaluation of the project?
  • How did this project improve upon or enhance student learning beyond the regular classroom curriculum?

Subcomponents

  • Value based on local action and impact
  • Content Connections
  • Student Participation
Component #2 - Long Term Environmental Impact / Total Possible - 30 points

Guiding Questions

  • What is the relationship between the goals, action plan and outcomes?
  • Are the project goals educational (e.g.,to inform others about an issue) or about environmental impact (e.g., to change the issues) or both?
  • How was this project important to students, the school and/or community?
  • Will we see the effects of this project in 5 years? What is (are) the enduring aspect(s) of this project?
  • How did students move from awareness, to stewardship and possible long-term, responsible action?

Subcomponents

  • Action Plan
  • Long-Term Benefit
Component #3 - Assessment and Reflection / Total Possible - 30 points

Guiding Questions

  • What is the evidence that the project was successful and is making a difference for students?
  • What is the evidence of student learning? How will that learning be sustained?
  • How did this project improve upon or enhance student learning beyond the regular classroom curriculum?
  • What is the evidence for changes in teacher’s thinking or practice?
  • What evidence does the teacher provide to determine the impact on student learning? How will that learning be sustained?
  • How did this project improve upon or enhance Teacher learning beyond the regular classroom curriculum?

Subcomponents

  • Student Self-Assessment and Reflection
  • Teacher Reflection
Component #4 - Portfolio Presentation / Total Possible - 15 points

Guiding Questions

  • Can the reader understand the goals and outcomes of project from the presentation?
  • How does the presentation demonstrate originality and creative efforts by the students and teacher?
  • How were students involved in completing the presentation of the project?

Subcomponents

  • Overall Quality of the Presentation of the Portfolio